When initiating a troubleshooting session with a customer, I aim to gather comprehensive information through a series of nine essential questions. These questions, designed to elicit detailed responses, form the backbone of an effective diagnostic process.
The Key Questions:
- What is happening?
- What did you expect to happen?
- When is it happening?
- When did it start happening?
- How does this problem affect you?
- What do you think the problem is, and what data are you basing this on?
- What have you tried so far?
- What is the expected resolution?
- Is there anything that would prohibit certain troubleshooting steps or solutions?
These open-ended questions may not always yield immediate answers. However, they guide the data-gathering process, helping to identify what additional information is needed to progress.
Assessing Information Reliability
Throughout the troubleshooting process, it’s crucial to evaluate the reliability of the information provided. Distinguishing between verified facts and hearsay prevents unnecessary diversions and keeps the focus on relevant issues.
The Power of Collaborative Problem-Solving
Explaining the problem to a colleague can often bring clarity. Verbalizing the issue forces you to organize your thoughts and can uncover new perspectives.
In-Depth Analysis of Key Questions
1. What is happening?
This question is fundamental to troubleshooting as it establishes the baseline of the problem. A precise understanding of the issue helps in formulating effective solutions. Here’s how to approach it:
- Encourage Detailed Descriptions: Ask for specific symptoms rather than general terms. For instance, instead of saying “the system crashes,” it’s more helpful to describe the exact behavior. Does it freeze, show an error message, or restart?
- Contextual Information: Understand the context in which the problem occurs. Is it during peak usage times, or when a specific function is being used? Knowing the circumstances can narrow down potential causes.
- Frequency and Duration: How often does the issue occur, and how long does it last? Regular occurrences can indicate a recurring issue that might be easier to track, while sporadic problems might require different diagnostic approaches.
- Verification of the Issue: Has the problem been observed internally, or is it based solely on user reports? Internal verification can confirm the problem’s existence and provide a controlled environment for testing solutions.
Example: “Once or twice a day over the last two weeks, customers report that the login page is not responding. If they wait long enough, the page times out. We’ve verified this behavior internally, noting that other pages remain functional during these incidents. The issue persists until we restart the application, and no relevant events appear in the event log.”
This detailed response highlights the frequency, internal verification, and specific conditions, allowing for more targeted troubleshooting.
2. What did you expect to happen?
Understanding expected outcomes is essential for contextualizing issues. Knowing what should have happened can provide insights into the deviation caused by the problem. This helps in understanding the severity and scope of the issue.
- Set Clear Baselines: For performance issues, establish what the normal response times are. For example, knowing that a page typically loads in under 2 seconds can highlight the severity if it now takes 10 seconds.
- Identify Expected Behavior: For functional problems, describe the expected behavior in detail. For instance, if an email notification is expected to be sent upon a specific action, confirming this helps in understanding the failure point.
- Compare Against Testing Data: Compare the expected outcomes with the results seen during testing or under controlled conditions. This comparison can help identify if the problem is due to unexpected conditions in the production environment.
Example: “In our load tests, the login page consistently responded in under 2 seconds. We expected similar performance in production. However, the page now takes over 10 seconds to respond, which significantly impacts user experience.”
3. When is it happening?
Identifying the timing and conditions under which the problem occurs is crucial. This helps in reproducing the issue and understanding its triggers.
- Frequency and Patterns: Determine if the problem happens at specific times or under certain conditions. Is it related to high user traffic or specific user actions?
- Reproducibility: Can the problem be consistently reproduced? Understanding the conditions that lead to the issue can help in diagnosing and resolving it.
- Environmental Factors: Consider whether external factors, such as network issues or server loads, could be contributing to the problem.
Example: “The issue occurs every weekday morning around 8 AM, coinciding with the peak login times as employees start their workday. This suggests a potential load-related problem.”
4. When did it start happening?
Determining the onset of the issue can correlate with recent changes or events, providing critical clues for root cause analysis.
- Recent Changes: Identify any changes made to the system, such as updates, new deployments, or configuration changes, around the time the issue started.
- Historical Data: Compare the current issue with historical data to see if similar problems occurred in the past. This can help in identifying patterns or recurring issues.
- Discovery vs. Onset: Differentiate between when the issue started and when it was first noticed. This helps in aligning the problem with specific changes or events.
Example: “The problem started immediately after the last system update, which included a new security patch. This suggests a potential issue with the update.”
5. How does this problem affect you?
Understanding the impact on the user helps prioritize troubleshooting efforts. Critical issues may necessitate immediate temporary fixes to maintain functionality while working on the root cause.
- User Impact: Determine how the issue affects users. Is it causing complete downtime, or is it a performance degradation?
- Business Impact: Assess the impact on business operations. Is it affecting critical functions or a subset of features?
- Severity and Priority: Based on the impact, prioritize the issue. Critical issues that affect many users or crucial business functions should be addressed with higher urgency.
Example: “The issue prevents users from logging in, which is critical as it affects daily operations and employee productivity. We need an immediate workaround to restore access while investigating the root cause.”
6. What do you think the problem is, and what data are you basing this on?
Gathering the customer’s perspective on the problem, along with supporting data, can uncover known problem areas. However, it’s important to validate this data independently to avoid bias.
- Customer Insights: Leverage the customer’s knowledge of their system. They might have insights based on past experiences or known issues.
- Supporting Data: Ask for logs, error messages, and other data that support their theory. This data can provide valuable clues.
- Independent Validation: Verify the customer’s data and theory independently. This helps in maintaining an unbiased approach to troubleshooting.
Example: “The customer suspects a memory leak due to increasing memory usage patterns observed in task manager. They have provided memory usage logs showing a steady increase over time.”
7. What have you tried so far?
Knowing previous attempts to resolve the issue prevents redundant efforts and provides additional data points from the outcomes of those actions.
- Documented Actions: Review any actions already taken and their outcomes. This includes temporary fixes, configuration changes, or attempted solutions.
- Effectiveness: Assess the effectiveness of previous attempts. Did any action improve the situation or provide more clues?
- Avoid Redundancy: Prevent repeating actions that have already been tried unless there is a reason to verify their outcomes independently.
Example: “The team has already tried restarting the application and clearing the cache, but the issue persists. They have also updated the database drivers, which did not resolve the problem.”
8. What is the expected resolution?
Clearly defining the desired outcome, whether it’s avoiding crashes or improving response times, sets a measurable goal for the troubleshooting process.
- Specific Goals: Define clear, specific goals for what constitutes a successful resolution. This helps in measuring progress and determining when the issue is resolved.
- Short-term vs. Long-term Solutions: Identify both short-term workarounds to mitigate immediate impact and long-term solutions to prevent recurrence.
- Stakeholder Agreement: Ensure all stakeholders agree on the expected resolution to align efforts and manage expectations.
Example: “The expected resolution is to reduce login page response times to under 2 seconds consistently and ensure the application does not require frequent restarts.”
9. Is there anything that would prohibit certain troubleshooting steps or solutions?
Understanding any limitations or constraints helps tailor the troubleshooting approach to feasible and acceptable actions.
- Technical Constraints: Identify any technical limitations, such as hardware capabilities or software dependencies, that could affect troubleshooting steps.
- Operational Constraints: Consider operational constraints, such as maintenance windows, user access requirements, or regulatory compliance.
- Resource Availability: Assess the availability of necessary resources, including personnel, tools, and data, for implementing solutions.
Example: “The application cannot be taken offline during business hours, which limits the ability to perform certain tests. Additionally, there are restrictions on installing third-party diagnostic tools due to security policies.”
Documentation and Summary
After gathering information, I compile a comprehensive summary that includes:
- Problem description
- Expected resolution
- Troubleshooting done
- Next steps
- Timeline for next steps
This structured format not only aids in tracking progress but also facilitates collaboration and handover, ensuring continuity and clarity in the troubleshooting process.
Azure Advice 